All posts:

The Greek geographical tradition

Notes

For the ancient Greeks, geography was synonymous with cartography

Examples include Eratosthenes and Ptolemy.

The Greek geographers traced their tradition back to the ancient poets, Homer and Hesiod, followed by Anaximander, "then Democritus and Eudoxus and Dicaearchus, Ephorus and a large number of others; and again, their successors, Eratosthenes, Polybius and Posidonius", as Schiöth abbreviates the list given by Strabo.

Both Homer and Hesiod depicted the earth as a flat circular disc surrounded by the river Oceanus, and Anaximander is credited with the first attempt at a world map on this basis, although lost. It is reconstructed in this example from WM Commons. (FP Note: the dividing lines between continents differ from those accepted later - here the Nile divides Africa from Asia and the Phasis (modern-day Rioni in Georgia) divides Europe from Asia.):

Hecataeus is said to have improved upon Anaximander’s map. Fragments of his Circuit of the …

The difficulty of measuring space and time

In antiquity, the positions of the stars could be measured, albeit crudely. Observations had shown that when one travelled north or south, the stars visible on any night of the year change. Further north, stars within a broad circle around the Pole Star are visible at all seasons, that is, they never set below the horizon. As you go south, this circle shrinks, but a greater number of equatorial stars become visible only sometimes and at some seasons. Contrastingly, when travelling east and west it was found that the same stars were visible at all locations along what could thus be defined as a line (really a circle) of latitude.

Similarly, measurements of the shadow cast by a gnonom – an upright stick in full sun – would give different results at different latitudes. By travelling up the River Nile past Aswan, one entered the tropical region, where the summer sun could …

Notes on Ptolemy’s Geography

Raw notes blog

This blog is a repository for my notes on historical topics, based on source texts of various kinds including primary sources and modern secondary works. It may not be all that readable, but will help me keep track of these sources which I may wish to refer to elsewhere. Much of it is connected to 17th and 18th century research I'm doing for my Substack newsletter Diamond Pitt.

However, I also have an interest in earlier history and in particular the development and transmission of knowledge about the world, in the form of ideas, inventions, beliefs and practices, from the early centuries of the Common Era onwards. My starting point is Ptolemy’s Geography, a landmark text from the mid-second century CE.

Claudius Ptolemy

Claudius Ptolemy (c. 100 CE – c. 180 CE) was an Alexandrian, and despite his name probably not related either to the Claudian or …